hardly Tarik Shah, a bassist of the New York scene who played with Ahmad Jamal, Betty Carter and Abbie Lincoln, among others, would have been more than a footnote on page in the history of jazz. But, as recently reported, Shah spent two years in prison on charges of cooperating with Al Qaeda and had sworn allegiance to bin Laden. According to the charges, the musician offered to train "brothers" in martial arts and weapons. Since then the world is revolutionized jazz. Howard Mandel, president of the Jazz Journalists Association, believes it was an attack on freedom of expression, among other constitutional rights violated. JB Spins, a professor of jazz and politics, countered that if the allegations are true, Shah would be rejecting the great jazz values: freedom, inclusion and artistic integrity. While a cursory reading of the history of the case revealed too many inconsistencies in the prosecution and at the same time, a flawed judicial action, the very possibility of this being true is what thrills, and concerns, all relating to a or another way to jazz.
is not, as rush to hold some, perhaps this is not a suitable music for more rigid cultural tenets of Islam. The jazz world is full of Muslims (Ahmad Jamal, Ibrahim Abdullah, Yusef Lateef) and many others, so this is not the contradiction. But the desire to kill for an ideal, whatever it was, a musician (if there is something true in this case) staged a number of opposites in one person. The ability to make beauty and horror, freedom-and Spins says, "that is inherent in jazz, with the bondage of death and terror. Actually, music does not relieve or absolve us of anything. The jazz world is full of villains, some of which have been in history as great heroes of the genre (think only of Chet Baker), and finally, the human capacity to do harm and beauty seem unlimited. However, the attitude of Howard Mandel and journalist specializing Margaret Davis (who has a website, http://tariksfriends.faithweb.com/ in this case) to support the Shah's innocence is the best, not just because of deficiencies in the indictment. Believe that jazz is a counterbalance, but pitiful and inadequate, against all the evils of this world can be a naive attitude, but somehow praises the one who holds it. Little more remains.
is not, as rush to hold some, perhaps this is not a suitable music for more rigid cultural tenets of Islam. The jazz world is full of Muslims (Ahmad Jamal, Ibrahim Abdullah, Yusef Lateef) and many others, so this is not the contradiction. But the desire to kill for an ideal, whatever it was, a musician (if there is something true in this case) staged a number of opposites in one person. The ability to make beauty and horror, freedom-and Spins says, "that is inherent in jazz, with the bondage of death and terror. Actually, music does not relieve or absolve us of anything. The jazz world is full of villains, some of which have been in history as great heroes of the genre (think only of Chet Baker), and finally, the human capacity to do harm and beauty seem unlimited. However, the attitude of Howard Mandel and journalist specializing Margaret Davis (who has a website, http://tariksfriends.faithweb.com/ in this case) to support the Shah's innocence is the best, not just because of deficiencies in the indictment. Believe that jazz is a counterbalance, but pitiful and inadequate, against all the evils of this world can be a naive attitude, but somehow praises the one who holds it. Little more remains.
column music section ABCD cultural supplement in the Arts and Letters on 5/12/2007.
0 comments:
Post a Comment